12. Are REIT Dividends Subject to the new 15 Percent Maximum Tax Rate?
In May 2003, the U.S. Congress passed the Jobs and Growth Tax Relief Reconciliation Act, which cut income tax rates on most dividends and capital gains to a 15 percent maximum. Because REITs do not generally pay corporate taxes, the majority of REIT dividends continue to be taxed as ordinary income at the maximum new rate of 35 percent (down from 38.6 percent).
However, REIT dividends will qualify for a lower tax rate in the following instances:
- When the individual taxpayer is subject to a lower scheduled income tax rate;
- When a REIT makes a capital gains distribution (15 percent maximum tax rate);
- When a REIT distributes dividends received from a taxable REIT subsidiary or other corporation (15 percent maximum tax rate); and
- When permitted, a REIT pays corporate taxes and retains earnings (15 percent maximum tax rate).
In addition, the maximum 15 percent capital gains rate applies generally to the sale of REIT stock.
Available data indicate that about 44 percent of REIT dividends qualified for the lower 15 percent capital gains rate in 2005. Of this amount, 36 percent represented capital gain distributions and 64 percent represented return of capital, which is taxed at a capital gain rate when the stock is sold.
RETURN TO THE TOP
13. What Real Estate Fundamentals Should I Consider Before Investing?
REIT investors often compare current stock prices to the net asset value (NAV) of a company's assets. NAV is the per share measure of the market value of a company's net assets. At times, the stock price of a REIT may be more or less than its NAV. Investors should understand some of the fundamental factors that influence the value of a REIT's real estate holdings. One critical factor is how well balanced the supply of new buildings is with the demand for new space. When construction adds new space into a market more rapidly than it can be absorbed, building vacancy rates increase, rents can weaken and property values decline, thereby depressing net asset values.
In a strong economy, growth in employment, capital investment and household spending increase the demand for new office buildings, apartments, industrial facilities and retail stores. Population growth also boosts the demand for apartments. However, the economy is not always equally strong in all geographic regions, and economic growth may not increase the demand for all property types at the same time. Thus, investors should compare the locations of properties of different companies with the relative strength or weakness of real estate markets in those locations.
Information on company properties is available at their Internet sites, while information on local and regional real estate markets is available in the financial press or at research sites on the Internet such as www.lendlease.com or www.tortowheatonresearch.com.
RETURN TO THE TOP
14. How has Real Estate Financing Changed Over Time?
Historically, income-producing commercial real estate often was financed with high levels of debt. Properties provided tangible security for mortgage financing, and the rental income from those properties was a clear source of revenue to pay the interest expense on the loan. Property markets often were dominated by developers or entrepreneurial businessmen who were attempting to build personal fortunes and who were willing to take on huge risks to do so. Prior to the real estate recession of the early 1990s, it was not uncommon for individual properties to carry mortgages that represented over 90 percent of the properties' estimated market value or cost of construction. Occasionally, loan-to-value ratios went even higher. The severe real estate recession of the early 1990s forced many real estate lenders, developers and owners to reconsider the appropriate use of debt financing on real estate projects.
Today, properties owned by REITs are financed on a much more conservative basis. On average, REITs are financing their projects with about half debt and half equity, which significantly reduces interest rate exposure and creates a much stronger and less volatile business operation. Two-thirds of the REITs with senior unsecured debt ratings are investment grade.
RETURN TO THE TOP
15. How are REIT Stocks Valued?
Like all companies whose stocks are publicly traded, REIT shares are priced every day in the market and give investors an opportunity to value their portfolios daily. To assess the investment value of REIT shares, typical analysis involves one or more of the following criteria:
- Management quality and corporate structure
- Anticipated total return from the stock, estimated from the expected price change and the prevailing dividend yield
- Current dividend yields relative to other yield-oriented investments (e.g. bonds, utility stocks and other high-income investments)
- Dividend payout ratios as a percent of REIT FFO
- Anticipated growth in earnings per share
- Underlying asset values of the real estate and/or mortgages, and other assets.
Stock of REITs that are registered with the SEC but not publicly traded on an exchange should be valued in consultation with a qualified financial advisor.
RETURN TO THE TOP
16. What Factors Contribute to REIT Earnings?
Growth in earnings typically comes from several sources, including higher revenues, lower costs and new business opportunities. The most immediate sources of revenue growth are higher rates of building occupancy and increasing rents. As long as the demand for new properties remains well balanced with the available supply, market rents tend to rise as the economy expands. Low occupancy in underutilized buildings can be increased when skilled owners upgrade facilities, enhance building services and more effectively market properties to new types of tenants. Property acquisition and development programs also create growth opportunities, provided the economic returns from these investments exceed the cost of financing. Like other public companies, REITs and publicly traded real estate companies also increase earnings by improving efficiency and taking advantage of new business opportunities.
The REIT Modernization Act (RMA), which took effect on January 1, 2001, provides REITs with other opportunities to increase earnings. Prior to the enactment of the RMA, REITs were limited to providing only those services that were long accepted as being "usual and customary" landlord services, and were restricted from offering more cutting-edge services provided by other landlords. The RMA allows REITs to create subsidiaries that can provide the competitive services that many of today's tenants desire.
RETURN TO THE TOP
17. Who Invests in REITs?
Tens of thousands of individual investors, both U.S. and non-U.S., own shares of REITs. Other typical buyers of REITs are pension funds,
endowment funds and foundations, insurance companies, bank trust departments and mutual funds.
Investors typically are attracted to REITs for their high levels of current income and the opportunity for moderate long-term growth. These are the basic characteristics of real estate. In addition, investors looking for ways to diversify their investment portfolios beyond other common stocks as well as bonds are attracted to the unique characteristics of REITs.
Today, a broad range of investors are using REITs to help achieve their investment goals, from large pension funds seeking diversification to the retired school teacher seeking a high-quality income investment.
Listed REIT shares may be purchased on the open market, with no minimum purchase required. Many investors also are choosing to own REITs through mutual funds or exchange traded funds that specialize in public real estate companies.
RETURN TO THE TOP
18. Why Should I Invest in REITs?
REITs are total return investments. They typically provide high dividends plus the potential for moderate, long-term capital appreciation. Long-term total returns of REIT stocks are likely to be somewhat less than the returns of higher risk high-growth stocks and somewhat more than the returns of lower risk bonds. Because most REITs also have a small-to-medium equity market capitalization, their returns should be comparable to other small to mid-sized companies.
There is a relatively low correlation between list REIT stock returns and the returns of other market sectors. Thus, including listed REITs in your investment program helps build a diversified portfolio.
REITs offer investors:
- Current, stable dividend income
- High dividend yields
- Dividend growth that has consistently exceeded the rate of consumer price inflation
- Liquidity: shares of publicly traded REITs are readily converted into cash because they are traded on the major stock exchanges
- Professional management: REIT managers are skilled, experienced real estate professionals
- Portfolio diversification, which reduces risk
- Oversight: Independent directors of the REIT, independent analysts, independent auditors, and the business and financial media monitor a public REIT's financial reporting on a regular basis. This scrutiny provides an investor a measure of protection and more than one barometer of the REIT's financial condition.
- Disclosure obligations: REITs whose securities are registered with the SEC are required to make regular SEC disclosures, including quarterly and yearly financial reports.
RETURN TO THE TOP
19. What Role do REITs Play in 401(k) Plans?
Most 401(k) plans offer a variety of stock and bond investment options. However, real estate is largely not accessible in most of today's
defined contribution plans. Real estate stocks' competitive rates of return, stable levels of risk, and low correlation with the investment returns of other stocks and bonds offer significant diversification benefits to a multi-asset portfolio. Participants and sponsors should make sure that their 401(k) plans include real estate—one of the strongest sources of portfolio diversification—among their investment choices. Historically, institutional investors have invested in broadly diversified portfolios of multiple investments, meeting their plan liabilities while controlling the risk of catastrophic losses in any one year. Individual investors may not understand the importance of this investment concept.
NAREIT commissioned Ibbotson Associates—a leading authority on asset allocation—to examine the historical investment performance of the publicly traded equities of REITs to determine if REITs provide meaningful diversification benefits in diversified portfolios. Ibbotson found that, historically, REITs have earned competitive returns and exhibited lower volatility than other types of stocks. Ibbotson also found that REIT returns are relatively uncorrelated with those of other stocks and bonds. In fact, as the total equity market capitalization of REITs increased and the companies achieved wider analytical coverage from Wall Street analysts and a broader base of investors, the correlation of REIT returns with those of other investments declined appreciably. As a result of these investment characteristics, the Ibbotson analysis demonstrates that REITs are a strong source of portfolio diversification, raising returns and lowering risk in a wide range of diversified portfolios.
For example, the analysis by Ibbotson found that allocating 10 percent of your portfolio to REITs each year from 1972 to 2005 would have boosted the average annual return from 10.7 percent to 11.0 percent while reducing portfolio risk from 11.0 percent to 10.7 percent. Allocating 20 percentage points to REITs would have boosted the average annual return to 11.4 percent while reducing portfolio risk to 10.6 percent. For more information on Ibbotson's study, visit their web site by clicking here.
RETURN TO THE TOP
20. If I Own a Home, do I Still Need to Invest in REITs?
REIT investing complements homeownership. While owning a home can be a good investment, the investment benefits are enhanced when combined with REIT stocks.
Importantly, homeownership differs from other investments in some significant ways. A house is an expenditure as much as it is an investment, particularly when financed with a sizeable mortgage. It does not produce current income, but rather requires regular mortgage interest, real estate tax and insurance payments plus other occasional expenditures to be properly maintained.
A widely-used index of single-family house prices nationwide gained 5.8 percent compounded on average from 1976 to 2003. Equity REITs, meanwhile, produced a 6.5 percent compound annual return on a price-only basis, but with dividends reinvested, REITs' compound annual total return for the span was 15.5 percent.
The low correlation between REIT returns and changes in house prices, combined with the historically attractive total return and moderate volatility of REITs, make it no surprise that REITs show up in the optimal portfolios estimated for both homeowners and renters.
In the final analysis, investors may be able to build greater long-term financial wealth when they combine homeownership and REIT stocks as part of a diversified investment portfolio.
RETURN TO THE TOP
21. What Should I Look for When Investing in a REIT?
The market usually rewards companies that demonstrate consistent earnings and dividend growth with higher price-earnings multiples. Thus,
investors should look for REITs and publicly traded real estate companies with the following characteristics:
- A demonstrated ability to increase earnings in a reliable manner. For example, look for companies with properties in which rents are below current market levels. Such properties provide upside potential in equilibrium markets and downside protection when economic growth slows.
- Management teams able to quickly and effectively reinvest available cash flow. The ability to consistently complete new projects on time and within budget. Creative management teams with sound strategies for developing new revenue opportunities under the REIT Modernization Act.
- Strong operating characteristics, including effective corporate governance procedures, conservative leverage, widely accepted accounting practices, strong tenant relationships and a clearly defined operating strategy for succeeding in competitive markets.
RETURN TO THE TOP
22. How do I Invest in a REIT?
An individual may invest in a publicly traded REIT, which is listed on a major stock exchange, by purchasing shares through a stockbroker. As with other publicly traded securities, investors may purchase common stock, preferred stock or debt securities. An investor can enlist the services of a broker, investment advisor or financial planner to help analyze his or her financial objectives. These professionals may be able to recommend appropriate REIT investments for the investor. An investor may also contact a REIT directly for a copy of the company's annual report, prospectus and other financial information. Much of this information is available on a company's web site. The NAREIT web site, www.nareit.com, also lists all publicly traded REITs with their exchange symbols. Many local libraries offer a wide range of publications which provide investment research and information on public companies such as REITs.
Another alternative is to diversify your investment further by buying shares in a mutual fund that specializes in investing in real estate securities. A list of such mutual funds is available at the NAREIT web site. Investors can compare and evaluate the performance of mutual funds through public information sources such as Morningstar, Inc., which can also be found in many local libraries. These sources can offer detailed information on past performance, current portfolio holdings and information dealing with the various costs of investing in funds. There
are also a number of real estate and REIT exchange traded funds and closed end funds.
RETURN TO THE TOP
23. How are REITs Different from Limited Partnerships?
REITs are not partnerships, although, as is the case with other corporations, REITs use partnerships to engage in joint ventures. There
are important organizational and operational differences between REITs and limited partnerships.
One of the major differences between REITs and limited partnerships is how annual tax information is reported to investors. Each year, an
investor in a REIT receives a traditional IRS Form 1099 from the REIT, indicating the amount and type of income received during the prior tax year. However, an investor in a partnership receives a more complicated IRS Schedule K-1 which must be furnished to taxpayers later in the year than a 1099. Also, a REIT investor must file fewer state tax returns than required by a partnership investment.
Many believe the corporate governance features of a REIT are superior to those of a partnership.
Other important differences between REITs and limited partnerships are summarized in the chart.
RETURN TO THE TOP
24. Can I Exchange Real Estate for REIT Stock as Part of a "Section 1031 Like Kind Exchange?
By way of background, section 1031 of the Internal Revenue Code generally permits tax deferral when investment property or property used in a trade or business is exchanged for "like kind" property as long as the exchange is completed within 180 days of the transfer of the exchanged property. Non-simultaneous exchanges are also permissible under section 1031 if certain criteria are met. These exchanges are known as "like kind exchanges." An example of a like kind exchange would be an exchange of an apartment building in Baltimore for an apartment building in San Diego. REIT stock does not qualify as investment property, and, accordingly, it is not possible to effect a like kind exchange of real estate for REIT stock.
Although REIT stock cannot qualify for like kind exchange treatment, another provision of U.S. tax law (Section 721 of the Internal Revenue Code) does permit owners of real property to exchange their property for partnership interests on a tax-deferred basis if certain conditions are met. Relying on this provision, many REITs own the majority, if not all, of their properties through an operating partnership ("OP") in which they hold the majority interests. The operating partnership most often pertains to an "umbrella partnership REIT" or "UPREIT," but also may pertain to a "DownREIT."
From time to time, real estate owners may transfer properties on a tax-deferred basis to an OP in exchange for OP units. The OP units ultimately are exchangeable into REIT stock or cash in a taxable transaction, and they allow their owners to receive partnership distributions typically similar to the REIT distributions they would receive had they converted the OP units into REIT stock. The web sites of many REITs contain information about transfers of properties in exchange for OP units.
RETURN TO THE TOP
25.What is "Unrelated Business Taxable Income" (UBTI) and can REIT dividends constitute UBTI?
In very general terms, "unrelated business taxable income" or UBTI is income earned by an otherwise tax-exempt entity that is considered taxable income to the entity, typically because it is derived from a business activity unrelated to the tax-exempt purpose of the entity. For example, an "individual retirement account" or IRA is typically considered tax-exempt, but if it earns UBTI, it must pay tax on that income.
In general, REIT dividends do not generate UBTI (at least no more than dividends from non-REIT stocks). See Revenue Ruling 66-106, in which the IRS specifically held that dividends from a REIT generally do not generate UBTI; and Revenue Ruling 2006-58, which held that a charitable remainder trust is not subject to unrelated business income tax as a result of being allocated excess inclusion income from a REIT. Nevertheless, there are exceptions to the general rule, such as when a pension plan owns more than 25 percent of a REIT's stock and in the case of certain mortgage REITs that use financings considered to be "taxable mortgage pools."
Because the answers to these questions are complex, it is important to consult with a competent tax advisor for answers applicable to your specific situation.